[Sokal Affair | Articles | Searching | Guestbook | Recent Additions]

View the old guestbooks from March 1996

June 30, 1996 to October 29, 1996



Carla R. Payne, cpayne@plainfield.bypass.com, visited on Sunday, June 30, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



J. A. Thomas, thomas@vaxa.clarion.edu, visited on Sunday, June 30, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



John McElroy, jhmcelroy@uta.edu, visited on Monday, July 01, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



Gerran Thomas, dgt@aber.ac.uk, visited on Tuesday, July 02, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



John N. Frary, stodgett@gnn.com, visited on Sunday, July 07, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



Urban Strandberg, Urban.Strandberg@CEFOS.gu.se, visited on Wednesday, July 10, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



ben goldacre, beng@mednuc.hsr.it, visited on Wednesday, July 10, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



Todd Ellner, tellner@cs.pdx.edu, visited on Thursday, July 11, 1996:
Message: Hurray for Dr. Sokal!
Web Page:



Tavia Fortt, RegencyElf@aol.com, visited on Thursday, July 11, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



ANDRÉS ARIAS ASTRAY, aarias@ualm.filabres.es, visited on Friday, July 12, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://www.ualm.es



Gary Woods, gwoods@quantum.ece.ucsb.edu, visited on Friday, July 12, 1996:
Message: Thanks for this interesting & informative site.
Web Page:



marie ebersole, mebersole@wellesley.edu, visited on Saturday, July 13, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



David J. Schuller, modern man in a post-modern world, schuller@uci.edu, visited on Saturday, July 13, 1996:
Message: Enjoyed the discussion. However there are additional questions which need to be considered, such as: Who will look after the concerns of the academic ambidextrous? If a deconstructionist falls on his face does he make a sound? And finally, how could anyone design and construct a miniature golf course without any windmills?
Web Page:



Carl Henrik Fredriksson, ch.fredriksson@mailbox.swipnet.se, visited on Monday, July 15, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



marianne maass, marianne.maass@utu.fi, visited on Tuesday, July 16, 1996:
Message:
Web Page: http://



Balouka Mardochée, balouka@monza.u-strasbg.fr, visited on Tuesday, July 16, 1996:
Message: MA student using the Sokal affair as case study
Web Page: http://



Jim Benton, jimbentn@sprynet.com, visited on Sunday, July 21, 1996:
Message: Sokol deserves a MacArthur Prize for the finest example of nonsense fighting in years, and thanks as well to you for collecting these articles. Btw, read the Australian attack on Sokol for a few good laughs.
[Brooklyn, United States]
Web Page: http://



Val Dusek, Valdusek@aol.com, visited on Sunday, July 21, 1996:
Message: This has been an extremely helpful page. My own views on the controversy are mixed, as I think Social Text's defenses are fairly lame, but that the more general conclusions that Sokal and others opposed to social constructionism in science studies a re unwarrented.
[Chester, NH 03036, United States]
Web Page: http://



Frode Grini, frode.grini@aschehoug.no, visited on Tuesday, July 23, 1996:
Message:
[Kolbotn, Norway]
Web Page: http://



arthur bass, arthur11@pipeline.com, visited on Thursday, July 25, 1996:
Message:
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Rolf G Norberg, lenaorolf@norbergnetwork.se, visited on Saturday, July 27, 1996:
Message:
[Lidingoe, Sweden]
Web Page: http://



Mark Clifton Ploskunak, mplosk@ibm.net, visited on Sunday, July 28, 1996:
Message: Excellent web page, designed to do what could be best about the Internet. I'm an "Old Leftest" as well; some friends and I have thought about starting the Recidivist movement; our motto," Getting stabbed in the eye with a sharp stick REALLY does hu rt." Sokal is to be congraduated for pointing out the sloppy thinking and general lack of rogor in the Us today - left, right and the "Silent Indifferent"
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



L Ramakrishnan, ramki@ccwf.cc.utexas.edu, visited on Wednesday, July 31, 1996:
Message: Thanks for setting up the Sokal page.
[Austin, United States]
Web Page: http://uts.cc.utexas.edu/~ramakris



Jean Paul Van Bendegem, jpvbende@vnet3.vub.ac.be, visited on Wednesday, July 31, 1996:
Message:
[Brussel, Belgium]
Web Page: http://



Kimon Roussopoulos, roussopoulos@dgm.epfl.ch, visited on Wednesday, July 31, 1996:
Message: An interesting compilation of articles. While generally I support the thesis of Prof. Sokal and his defenders, I have to say that I found his original article so inpenetrable that it was not obviously a hoax to me (as a post-doctoral Engineer) - it had so much jargon in it that is removed from everyday discourse that it meant nothing to me, but might have meant something to someone somewhere. The defence offered by the editors is not without some merit. In the end we all have had a good laugh, but I don't think there are any deep morals to be drawn from this story.
[Lausanne, Switzerland]
Web Page: http://imhefwww.epfl.ch/lmf/staff/members/roussop/



Jan Witkowski, witkowsk@cshl.org , visited on Thursday, August 01, 1996:
Message: A very useful and interesting compilation.
[Cold Spring Harbor, United States]
Web Page: http://www.cshl.org/admin/pubaff/Banbury



Patrick Peccatte, peccatte@club-internet.fr, visited on Friday, August 02, 1996:
Message: Merci pour votre site très utile. Je trouve toutefois que l'"affaire" en question reste très contestable tant par la méthode peu courtoise employée par le professeur Sokal que par ses présupposés envers les "cultural studies" et ses effets pervers. Je m’explique très brièvement. - La moquerie peut difficilement constituer la base d’un dialogue constructif - que tout le monde s’accorde à juger nécessaire - entre la culture scientifique et la culture humaniste. La dérision et l’ironie témoignent plus dans le cas de l’article de Sok al d’une présomption de supériorité de la première sur la seconde que d’un effort mutuel de compréhension. - La crédulité et la naïveté d’un jugement ne disqualifient pas ipso facto son auteur, et il existe également des supercheries ou des tricheries dont certains scientifiques soi-disant mieux pourvus en "esprit critique" furent l’objet ; on peut citer l’aff aire de l’homme de Piltdown ou celle des autographes de Chasles par exemple... - La "post-tendency" (le postisme comme l’appelle Habermas) constitue un courant critique légitime et a produit également des analyses judicieuses (si) et intelligibles (re-si) pour un lecteur de culture ou de sensibilité scientifique, voire positiviste. Je pense par exemple aux travaux de Brian Rotman sur la sémiotique des mathématiques. On doit prendre garde à ne pas jeter l’eau du bain (le verbiage) avec le bébé (le criticisme). Cela ne signifie d’ailleurs pas que ces analyses ne puissent être soumises à une critique parfois sévère, y compris de la part d’autre courants philosophiques. Cela m’amène au point suivant : - Le "postisme" ne constitue pas un courant unifié, et, encore moins, ne saurait être identifié à la philosophie dans son ensemble. Pour reprendre deux points soulevés par Sokal, le problème de la dichotomie fait-valeur est également abordé par des philos ophes aussi différents que Putnam ou Habermas, et la question de la possibilité de tracer une ligne de démarcation entre les disciplines scientifiques et celles qui ne le sont pas reste très débattue par la philosophie analytique ou la sociologie des scie nces (pour ne citer que ces courants) lorsque l’on s’intéresse à certaines spécialités comme les sciences cognitives, la théorie des systèmes, la théorie des catastrophes, etc. P. Peccatte Informaticien (... et philosophe)
[Paris, France]
Web Page: http://www.rever.fr/cr/



Neal Evans, nce@uab.edu, visited on Friday, August 02, 1996:
Message: Socrates' stuggle continues. Can we ever eradicate sophistry?
[Birmingham, United States]
Web Page: http://www.phy.uab.edu/~nevans



Jyoo-Hi Rhee, jrhee@ix.urz.uni-heidelberg.de, visited on Friday, August 02, 1996:
Message:
[Heidelberg, Germany]
Web Page:



James E. Blevins, jblevins@mcs.kent.edu, visited on Friday, August 02, 1996:
Message: The arrogance and ignorance of the "cultural studies" partisans is most obvious in their writings on mathematical science, but has been most damaging to literarary study itself. I recommend POLITICS BY OTHER MEANS by David Bromwich--of the Yale (!) English Dept. & a essayist for DISSENT & THE NEW REPUBLIC-- for its accounts & critque of this academic left and its characteristic sloppiness (and of the less influential conservative, William Bennett). Can you collect links to critiques of "cultural studies" by humanities scholars? Keep up the good work!
[Kent, United States]
Web Page: http://TBA



Elliott Levinthal, levinthal@sunrise.stanford.edu, visited on Monday, August 05, 1996:
Message:
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Elliott Levinthal, Levinthal@!sunrise.stanford.edu, visited on Monday, August 05, 1996:
Message: See "Sokal's Hoax - Steven Weinberg New York Review of Books August 8, 1996
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Carlo Lepori, lepori@idsia.ch, visited on Tuesday, August 06, 1996:
Message:
[Lugano, Switzerland]
Web Page: http://www.idsia.ch/~carlo



Mik Bickis, bickis@snoopy.usask.ca, visited on Tuesday, August 06, 1996:
Message: Prof. Sokal gave me a copy of his Social Text paper dead-pan in May, just before the NYT article appeared. I read the first section in a state of innocence. I found it rather bizarre, coming from him, but it was not dissimilar in style and content from other works I have seen on such topics, if perhaps overly heavy on the jargon. (I winced at "hermeneutics" in the title.) I scanned the bibliography, finding some works I had read, and being surprised at the absence of Roger Penrose, who might have had some thoughts about quantum gravity. I told Sokal that I found his paper "interesting", meaning that there were some ideas there that might lead to good discussions. A colleague clued me into the hoax before I got further, so I can't honestly say what I thought after I finished the paper, but I think it is about five pages in before I would have realized the joke. It does get progressively more hokey as you continue. The choicest stuff is in the end-notes. I don't think this paper has demolished the social studies of science, and I commend this web site for providing links to diverse responses to the affair. Probably the best spin-off to Sokal's joke was the interest it has stimulated on this issue.
[Saskatoon, Canada]
Web Page:



Rick Martin, rfm@entropy.phy.ilstu.edu, visited on Tuesday, August 06, 1996:
Message: Useful compilation for the neophyte reader. I am planning to discussing the controversy in a new general education physics course "Chaos and Complexity" I am developing.
[Normal, United States]
Web Page: http://



Patrick Hamlett, phamlett@ncsu.edu, visited on Friday, August 09, 1996:
Message:
[Raleigh, United States]
Web Page: http://www2.ncsu.edu/ncsu/chass/mds/hamlett.html



mahesh baranwal, mpbaranw@midway.uchicago.edu, visited on Friday, August 16, 1996:
Message:
[Chicago, United States]
Web Page: http://



Søren Holm, S.Holm@Medphil.ku.dk, visited on Tuesday, August 20, 1996:
Message: Great page and great story!
[Copenhagen, Denmark]
Web Page: http://



John Argue, jargue@a.crl.com, visited on Thursday, August 22, 1996:
Message: Great resource page! Now, where's the one on Fred Crews taking down the Freud establishment? There should be an "Emporer's New Clothes" Oscar!
[Albany, CA, United States]
Web Page: http://

See also, Burying Freud: The Web Site [jwalsh]



Roben Torosyan, rqt8418@is4.nyu.edu, visited on Friday, August 23, 1996:
Message: My MA thesis was: "The Interconnections of Quantum Physics, Chaos Theory and Deconstruction: The Paradox of the Unnameable." (no joke)
[New York, United States]
Web Page: http://



Wayne Bishop, wbishop@calstatela.edu, visited on Thursday, August 29, 1996:
Message: Absolutely superb. Regrettably I am finding a subset of university education experts who are far into the science ain't real religion. This can only help. Thank you for your contribution to rational discourse.
[Los Angeles, United States]
Web Page: http://



John Duskin, mthduskn@ubvms.cc.buffalo.edu, visited on Friday, August 30, 1996:
Message: This is a superb site. Thank you very much for your efforts!
[Buffalo, United States]
Web Page: http://



Robin Markwitz, rmarkowitz@earthlink.net, visited on Sunday, September 01, 1996:
Message: Superb and needed project. Well done! (Check out my commentary on the immediate responses to the hoax by the victims at http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarkowitz/sokal.html )
[Torrance, CA, United States]
Web Page: http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarkowitz/



Cezar Ionescu, cezar@doodecas3.ici.ro, visited on Monday, September 02, 1996:
Message:
[Bucharest, Romania]
Web Page: http://



Sonja Laden, sonjamay@post.tau.ac.il, visited on Wednesday, September 04, 1996:
Message: About time! The Hoax and Debate are long overdue.
[Tel Aviv, Israel]
Web Page: http://



Alfonso de Castro, decastro@encomix.es, visited on Thursday, September 05, 1996:
Message:
[, Spain]
Web Page: http://



Thomas Kiraly, tkiraly@luna.cas.usf.edu, visited on Friday, September 06, 1996:
Message:
[Tampa, United States]
Web Page: http://



Ross Kiester, ross@krait.fsl.orst.edu, visited on Friday, September 06, 1996:
Message:
[Corvallis, OR, United States]
Web Page:



M. Robert Showalter, showalte@macc.wisc.edu, visited on Saturday, September 07, 1996:
Message: The fact that LARGE groups of self-validating, academically supported people can be involved with total nonsense (or simply involved in mistakes) says something about the "self cleansing" nature of science and the academy. Sokal's hoax, and this home page are MAJOR public services. I'm grateful to see the work.
[madison, United States]
Web Page: http://



Mads Hjorth, mads142@emil.ruc.dk, visited on Monday, September 09, 1996:
Message: We are a group of students at Roskilde University planning to write a project on the sokal affair. Thanks for the links, i think they will be very usefull.
[Copenhagen, Denmark]
Web Page: http://



ALLAN SHAND, GALANT@IHUG.CO.NZ, visited on Saturday, September 14, 1996:
Message: ALE 40 FROM NEW ZEALAND SEEKING YOUNG LADY FOR FRIENDSHIP
[AUCKLAND, New Zealand]
Web Page: http://

Different uses for different people. [jwalsh]



Robert Snower, rs222@worldnet.att.net, visited on Saturday, September 14, 1996:
Message: I enjoyed make these things available to me. Thank you.
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Pekka Puupää, , visited on Tuesday, September 17, 1996:
Message: Olen suomalainen ja minulla on kukka hatussani.
[Vasa, Finland]
Web Page: http://



Howard Schwartz, Schwartz@Oakland.edu, visited on Wednesday, September 18, 1996:
Message:
[Milford, Michigan, United States]
Web Page: http://www.sba.oakland.edu/faculty/schwartz/schwartz.htm



Jim Sweeney, swimgeni@aol.com, visited on Wednesday, September 18, 1996:
Message: Great job assembling the source material. It makes it very easy for a bystander to enter the conversation and learn a great deal at the same time
[Berkeley, United States]
Web Page: http://



Peter Bongaarts, bongaart@lorentz.leidenuniv.nl, visited on Friday, September 20, 1996:
Message: A fascinating collection!
[Leiden, Netherlands]
Web Page: http://



Bushrod Gorsky, , visited on Saturday, September 21, 1996:
Message: SOCIAL TEXT provided a forum for the marketplace of ideas. Isn't that what they're supposed to do? Mr Sokal then aborted the process before the community of scholars could apply the appropriate market forces - for which, I suspect, more than one sch olar will always be eternally grateful.
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Jonathan W. Mills, jwmills@cs.indiana.edu, visited on Sunday, September 22, 1996:
Message: Social validation of paradigms in science continues to be relevant. In my research into general purpose analog computation I have discovered just how true this is: the paradigm for computation dependent on concrete (and abstract) analogies died a little-recognized death by the mid-1970's. My recent attempts to revive that paradigm have led from initial rejection of the work as a valid field of study to a small but growing acceptance of its merit. But along the way the resemblance of computer sci ence, and its acceptable topic areas, have become more and more similar to the paradigms described by Kuhn, Brannigan, and Goldstein & Goldstein (their description of the Azande belief in witchcraft correlates amazingly to Weinberg's description of the ex planatory powers of computer programmers in "The Psychology of Computer Programming"). Perhaps more than any of the experimental sciences, computer science, with its blend of mathematics and pragmatic application, deserves to be studied as a shared parad igm.
[Bloomington, United States]
Web Page: http://www.cs.indiana.edu/hyplan/jwmills



William P. Banks, wbanks@pomona.edu, visited on Sunday, September 22, 1996:
Message: I thank you for maintaining this page, and I am glad you are keeping it up. Here in Claremont (the Claremont Colleges) I have found some extremely radical social constructivists, and I am very grateful to have your page as a resource to use to keep up with developments in the "Sokal affair." I find that some of the so-called humanists in this debate are somewhat ignorant of science. This is our legacy I fear for not teaching it well enough for "non-majors" and for bypassing questions of philosophy in our classes. I surmise ignorance from such things as discussions of "reductionism" in a way that makes it clear that the meaning of the word is not understood. If one could forget that the Sokal piece is intended as a parody, it could be used as a catalog of some of the silly positions people ignorant of science might take. My fear about the controversy is that it will cause the scientists to forget that science is indeed a cultural product, and to dismiss as hogwash many concerns about the misuse of science and the relations between science and society. It would be nice if some of the articles and editorials -- like Fish's in the NY Times -- could be put up verbatim. Bill Banks
[Claremont, CA 91711, United States]
Web Page: http://psych.pomona.edu



alton d. morris, altond@n-link.com, visited on Sunday, September 22, 1996:
Message: great!
[kempner, tx, United States]
Web Page: http://



James D. White, jwhite@hawaii.edu, visited on Tuesday, September 24, 1996:
Message: Excellent site.
[Honolulu, United States]
Web Page: http://



Anthony D. Elmendorf, aelmendo@math.purdue.edu, visited on Thursday, September 26, 1996:
Message:
[South Bend, IN, United States]
Web Page:



George H. Wahl, Jr., george_wahl@ncsu.edu, visited on Monday, September 30, 1996:
Message: Great Job! Please maintain and update. This should be required reading for all graduating seniors in the sciences.
[Raleigh, United States]
Web Page: http://www2.ncsu.edu/ncsu/chemistry/ghw.html



krivine Hubert, krivine@inpcls.in2p3.fr, visited on Thursday, October 03, 1996:
Message: Excellente page. Excellent travail aussi du Pr. Sokal !
[Paris, France]
Web Page: http://



McKenzie Wark, mwark@laurel.ocs.mq.edu.au, visited on Thursday, October 03, 1996:
Message: Remarkably comprehensive
[Sydney, Australia]
Web Page: http://www.mcs.mq.edu.au/~mwark



Kenji Ito, kenjiito@fas.harvard.edu, visited on Friday, October 04, 1996:
Message:
[Cambridge, United States]
Web Page: http://www.fas.harvard.edu/~kito



robin m w anscomb, anscomb@geko.net.au, visited on Saturday, October 05, 1996:
Message: hurrah for us!
[sydney, Australia]
Web Page: http://



Ted Striphas, , visited on Saturday, October 05, 1996:
Message: The "Sokal affair" was profoundly disastrous because it (re)produced a debate precisely in the terms that spawned it in the first place.
[Chapel Hill, NC, United States]
Web Page: http://



Paulo Lemos, paulo@turing.unicamp.br, visited on Sunday, October 06, 1996:
Message: Congratulations for the initiative!!
[Campinas, Brazil]
Web Page: http://www.unicamp.br/~plemos



Knut Ove Hauge, ovehauge@online.no, visited on Monday, October 07, 1996:
Message: Interested in fractal physics? Look at http://home.sol.no/ovehauge/
[Stavanger, Norway]
Web Page: http://home.sol.no/ovehauge/



Nancy Gallagher, gallaghe@humanitas.ucsb.edu, visited on Monday, October 07, 1996:
Message: I am looking for responses by the other authors in the Spring/Summer issue of Social Text. Thanks, Nancy Gallagher
[Santa Barbara, United States]
Web Page: http://



joao de mello, jtmn@dinfo.uerj.br, visited on Monday, October 07, 1996:
Message:
[rio de janeiro, Brazil]
Web Page: http://



Erin Pizzey, pizzey@sienanet.itSiena, visited on Wednesday, October 09, 1996:
Message: We will never alleviate suffering in relationships until we become aware of all our emotions that are to be found in the chemicals of the brain. Love is an addiction just like heroin and morphene. The feminists have confused the issue of violence in realtionsips with their need to fund their movement. Both men and women are equally violent but the difference lies in the expression of violence. Next month is the twenty-fifth anniversary of the founding of my refuge - the first in the world in Chi swick, London. There is little to celebrate - the movement was hi-jacked by women academics who had a hidden agenda that needed funding.
[Siena, Italy]
Web Page: http://



Nicholas Heer, heer@u.washington.edu, visited on Wednesday, October 09, 1996:
Message: Finally someone has deconstructed Postmodernism!
[Seattle, WA, United States]
Web Page: http://weber.u.washington.edu/~heer/



Arline R. Thorn, athorn@wvsvax.wvnet.edu, visited on Thursday, October 10, 1996:
Message:
[Institute, WV, United States]
Web Page: http://



CLIFF AUSTIN, AUSTINCO@GATE.NET, visited on Thursday, October 10, 1996:
Message: GOT HERE BY SEARCHING HOKEY BULLSHIT ON WEBCRAWLER STILL DON'T QUITE KNOW WHAT THIS IS ABOUT BUT THANKS ANYWAY.
[TAMPA, United States]
Web Page: http://WWW.THEAUSTINCONNECTION.COM



George Avrunin, avrunin@math.umass.edu, visited on Thursday, October 10, 1996:
Message:
[Amherst, MA, ]
Web Page: http://math.umass.edu/~avrunin



Eugene Barth, ebarth@rover.bsd.uchicago.edu, visited on Thursday, October 10, 1996:
Message:
[Chicago, United States]
Web Page: http://



Ernest Migliaccio, miggs@mail.idt.net, visited on Monday, October 14, 1996:
Message:
[New York, United States]
Web Page: http://



Dan Weiskopf, Daniel_Weiskopf@Brown.Edu, visited on Monday, October 14, 1996:
Message: I am a graduate student in the philosophy department at Brown University. Personal and professional information about me is available from the Brown University online directory, somewhere under http://www.brown.edu.
[Providence, United States]
Web Page: http://



Dr. Gary Holcomb, Armstrong Atlantic State Univ., visited on Tuesday, October 15, 1996:
Message: I would like to thank you for this project. Some faculty her at AASU are beginning a cultural theory reading group, and we have decided to begin with the Sokal affair. My email: Gary_Holcomb@mailgate.armstrong.edu
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Eric Nye, nye@uwyo.edu, visited on Tuesday, October 15, 1996:
Message: This page represents a real service to the academy. Don't let imaginary pressures from your sysop persuade you to take it down for at least a couple years!
[Laramie, United States]
Web Page: http://



Michael Koplow, mkoplow@shrike.depaul.edu, visited on Wednesday, October 16, 1996:
Message:
[Chicago, United States]
Web Page: http://www.period@at/virgule~squiggloidal-object



Peter Campbell, peter.campbell@uregina.ca, visited on Friday, October 18, 1996:
Message:
[Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada]
Web Page: http://



R. Acuna, ralph@admu.edu.ph, visited on Saturday, October 19, 1996:
Message:
[, Phillippines]
Web Page: http://



Bill Wilson, william@gis.uwa.edu.au, visited on Monday, October 21, 1996:
Message: The Sophists are alive and well in Australian Universities.
[Perth, Australia]
Web Page: http://



M. L. FalerSweany, mfsweany@mtu.edu, visited on Tuesday, October 22, 1996:
Message:
[Houghton, MI 49931, United States]
Web Page: http://



Craig K. Barber, csbarber@earthlink.net, visited on Tuesday, October 22, 1996:
Message:
[San Francisco, United States]
Web Page: http://



Zerxes Spencer, zspencer@midway.uchicago.edu, visited on Tuesday, October 22, 1996:
Message:
[, United States]
Web Page: http://



Stephen R.L.Clark, srlclark@liverpool.ac.uk, visited on Friday, October 25, 1996:
Message: Congratulations on a well-organised collection, with an abiding moral.
[Liverpool, United Kingdom]
Web Page: http://www.liv.ac.uk/~srlclark/philos.html



Philip J. Hughes, pjhughes@islandnet.com, visited on Sunday, October 27, 1996:
Message:
[Salt Spring Island, Canada]
Web Page: http://www.islandnet.com/~pjhughes/homepage.html



John T. Staff, j.t.staff@filosofi.uio.no, visited on Tuesday, October 29, 1996:
Message:
[Oslo, Norway]
Web Page: http://